At Christmas, How This Jew Understands Jesus (re-post)

From jump let me say that what I believe about the man is not devotional. No remotely Jewish notion of God--and we do know that he emerges, in Christian texts themselves, wholly sprung from Judaism--can sustain the idea of human blood atonement for sin (or for anything else). Judaism quite early and decisively rejects human sacrifice for any reason when God's messenger explicitly forbids Abraham, wholly prepared to show obedience by slaughtering his son, from wielding the dagger.

I cannot imagine (nor can any Rabbi or biblical historian contemplate) any Judaism or any idea born of Judaism upending that paradigm. That Isaac-story is about ultimate loyalty to the Unseen and a thoroughgoing renunciation of previous ancient Near East norms, of any ideology remotely condoning human blood atonement or sacrifice for any purpose.

In other words, while Christianity may have been born of Judaism in a specific time and place, Judaism and Christianity, philosophically, could not be more distant from one another: for Jews, human blood atonement is a thoroughly pagan idea.

Yet, short of the divine, I am thoroughly comfortable with a Jesus of a remarkable immediate and historical presence, intellect, charisma, and of a wholly Jewish philosophical nuance.

Prophet? I don't know and I'm not sure it matters.

What I do know is that he grew up in an occupied Israel strangled by foreigners for hundreds of years and by, in his day, Rome, the most routinely voracious, brutal regime in western history before the Nazis.

--In Judea (southern Israel) alone, Rome records 50,000 Jews crucified in the fifty years after his birth. You can do that math and know how routine a sight the lined up nailed corpses were.

And that was the point: while crucifixion was used all over the empire, it was used in Judea daily precisely because Rome knew that it was a slap to the God and the Law of the Jews to allow a body to remain in the open after sundown.

--In the twenty years prior to and after Jesus' murder, hundreds, if not thousands, of miracle-men went out to the Judean desert, starved- themselves-silly, returned through the city gates ranting about the Coming and the Presence (and Rome's imminent, miraculous collapse)... nearly all cast off as lunatics by their own families and by the mob. (Jesus, too, the gospels relate, speaks about prophets being unwelcome in their home towns and rejection by their families.) We read of the more successful ones, magicians such as Honi-The-Circle-Maker, credited with mass- and random (distant and immediate) healings and feedings and many other good works before the Jesus of the gospels.

Historian Josephus even speaks of a man, Jesus (another Jesus), so loud in his messianic assurances to the sleeping city night after night, four years or so after The Crucifixion, that he was roughly taken up by those just wanting sleep -- that poor man was not heard from again.

And there was yet another messianic character with followers, three or so years after the gospels' Jesus, who threw rock after rock at well-armed Roman soldiers in the Temple Precinct, at the Passover. One Roman archer who couldn't take it any longer shot the stone-thrower from a Temple parapet, causing a panic in which 30,000 Jews and Romans were trampled to death in minutes.

What does this tell me?

If nothing else, it tells me that the gospels' Jesus was, without question, had to be, a stand-out among stand-outs, among the most spectacularly gifted men of his or of any generation. None of these others, not a one, gets the ink, anything remotely like the painstaking devotional-histories this man received.

And understand: in the ancient Mediteranean there was no history, no biography among the masses or the elites (even in oral literature) that looked anything like what we agree is biography. All biography was religious/devotional. Even the court biographers of the Roman Emperor Augustus/Octavian wrote of a miraculous winter solstice virgin birth a century before Mark's and then Matthew's gospels subverted traditional ancient literature's social class expectation by recording a miraculous virgin birth for a rural boy born in a shed for animals.

And this isn't to denigrate Jesus.

It is a metaphor, a measure of what must have been his overwhelming interpersonal power and philosophical vision in a radically anti-Roman, radically communitarian and very Jewish theological context that an almost certainly illiterate Gallilean carpenter's boy became the subject and object of this fierce reaction while he lived, as well as an object of post-death devotion, devotion to the point of closest friends' certainty that they saw and spoke with him (beginning with his friend, Mary) days after his murder.

He was a man who could lay out a convincing potential for a world free of oppression, full of decency..."it is all laid out here before you".... His is the very traditional Jewish idea that the Kingdom of God is here, is now, if people will only grab it, grasp it, through the (again subversive and action-inducing modeling-metaphors of all classes) eating at a common table, multiplying loaves and fish for the hungry, all through a desire for common uplift and not just that of the few...metaphors and modeling, performances that announce not a world of venal division enthrall to personal and cultural greed but one devoted to the Jewish God's Justice.

His is an essential vision about as powerful a personal and political and socioeconomic vision as you can find, and again, it's one wholly embedded in a communitarian Jewish Justice-tradition.

Consider the raw visceral and heady power this man must have had to convince so many in his own rather barbaric time and place, that Justice was possible, that Justice remains, possible.

Views: 80

Comments are closed for this blog post

Comment by Jonathan Wolfman on December 24, 2018 at 7:44am

Excellent holidays to all. 

Comment by Dicky Neely on December 24, 2018 at 10:41am

To you as well Jonathan. Interesting piece...

Comment by Jonathan Wolfman on December 24, 2018 at 11:13am


Comment by koshersalaami on December 24, 2018 at 11:48am

My wife just texted this to me from Facebook

Comment by Jonathan Wolfman on December 24, 2018 at 11:53am


Comment by Ron Powell on December 24, 2018 at 3:33pm

Jesus was Jewish.

The world's first superstar., and Christianity is an enduring cult of his personality....

A personality that is a mystery....

I can accept all but the notion that Jesus was illiterate...Several years are absent/missing from his 'biography'.

I am convinced that he became learned during the period for which we have no reliable account...

Nicely written, Wolfman....And very powerful....

Comment by Jonathan Wolfman on December 24, 2018 at 8:31pm

thanks, Ron :)

Comment by Tom Cordle on December 25, 2018 at 9:42am

for Jews, human blood atonement is a thoroughly pagan idea

I stopped singing in the choir at church, in part because I simply couldn't abide the Easter tradition of wallowing in blood. The very idea of human sacrifice as expiation for sins is as barbaric a notion as I can imagine, and today's putative Christians would reject (hopefully) that idea in any other context – though the worst among them are apparently still in favor of stoning gays or throwing them over a cliff. It's in the Book, so they say, without any apparent understanding that the sum and substance of Jesus' teaching was forgiveness and love.

Speaking of "sum", Jesus' most misunderstood teaching was the idea that this is not a zero-sum game, that is to say, for me to win, someone else must lose. "Sell all you have and give to the poor" is far too hard a teaching to be practiced by the vast majority of Jesus' putative followers, some of whom even embrace the heretical Prosperity Gospel. Jesus said the Kingdom of Heaven is at hand; what he might have added is that to get there; you must first unclench your fist.

Comment by Jonathan Wolfman on December 25, 2018 at 9:52am

Tom   very well-put. 

Excellent '19 to you.



Posted by John Manchester on May 21, 2019 at 10:33am 0 Comments

The Pace Quickens

Posted by Robert B. James on May 21, 2019 at 6:11am 1 Comment


Posted by koshersalaami on May 20, 2019 at 5:53pm 15 Comments

The Wall

Posted by Steel Breeze on May 20, 2019 at 11:43am 3 Comments

A Little Spanish Night Music

Posted by Rodney Roe on May 20, 2019 at 9:49am 7 Comments

Now Now

Posted by Robert B. James on May 20, 2019 at 7:51am 4 Comments

The Final Frontier

Posted by Robert B. James on May 19, 2019 at 7:34am 2 Comments

© 2019   Created by lorianne.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service